Wednesday reading meme

Thu, 30 May 2013 02:42:55 GMT

What I've been reading

I read Tolkien's unfinished alliterative Arthur poem, The Fall of Arthur, which is good and quite good in bits, although man, Tolkien does not have much sympathy for poor Guinever. Lancelot gets some of my favorite parts, though:

There Lancelot over leagues of sea
in heaving welter from a high window
looked and wondered alone musing.
Dark slowly fell. Deep his anguish
He his lord betrayed to love yielding,
and love forsaking lord regained not;
faith was refused him who had faith broken,
by leagues of sea from love sundered.

Christopher Tolkien's notes are exhaustive and dull. Tolkien's own words on Anglo-Saxon poetry, adapted from a 1938 BBC broadcast, are briefer but livelier.

I read the two books in Diana Wynne Jones's Magids duology, Deep Secret and The Merlin Conspiracy. (Actually, I started reading The Merlin Conspiracy first, and then realized it had to be a sequel to something and ordered Deep Secret from the library.) They sit pretty oddly next to each other, since I would say Deep Secret is pretty clearly adult fiction and The Merlin Conspiracy is just as clearly juvenile fiction (as indeed they are placed in my library system). I totally adored Deep Secret, which is very clever and funny and typically Diana Wynne Jones, in spite of the fact that I pretty much anti-ship ( shippy spoilers under this cut )

Quite a lot of people seem to dislike The Merlin Conspiracy, whereas allowing for audience/genre shift I liked it, especially since Nick is my absolute favorite character from Deep Secret and I like what it does with him as a POV character very much. It feels much more like a Chrestomanci book. I can actually get behind ( more shippy spoilers )

I read the The Art Forger, a book I picked up off the new books shelf at the library, because who doesn't like art forgers? It is a fun, twisty story based around the Isabella Gardner Museum heist.

I read the second, third and fourth books in Maurice Druon's Accursed Kings series, the ones that George R. R. Martin is promoting in their new printings as "the original Game of Thrones", and deservedly so as there are marked similarities to his own work — a plot revolving around a royal succession clusterfuck, a broad scope of action and a range of variously likable POV characters and even magic (well, magic that the characters believe in, anyway). Of course, spoilers are a lot easier to come by, since you can just google the French kings of the 14th century, but you read for the page-turniness and the actual historical facts are a bonus.

Although I got the first book, The Iron King, from the library in the new printing, I just have really badly OCR'd copies of the next five, and the seventh hasn't been published in English yet at all, so I'm planning to take a run at in French and maybe really improve my vocabulary regarding pieces of armor and other late medieval type things.

What I'm reading now

The fifth Accursed Kings book, The She-Wolf of France. (It sounds better in the original where wolf is more naturally genderable: La Louve de France.)

What I'm reading next

As above, the sixth and hopefully also the seventh book.

comments

Shipping all the Gandalf rarepairs

Thu, 24 Jan 2013 22:28:58 GMT

I have finally seen The Hobbit Episode I ~~The Phantom Dragon~~, so I am feeling more like a fully-topped-up member of this fandom. (I still have not finished my The Hobbit reread, however. Shhh, don't tell anyone.)

I quite liked it! On one hand, it doesn't stand on its own very well and I wouldn't even recommend it to introduce someone to the LOTR movieverse, much less to Tolkien fandom generally. On the other hand, if I had that kind of budget to produce a fanwork and I knew it was going to be my last opportunity to do so, I would indulge all of my whims and fancies, too.

( Discussion of adaptation choices cut for people who are more behind than I am and who also consider adaptation choices to be a form of spoiler )

After the movie was over, my mom, who is a strictly movie verse-only fan, asked me why Bilbo had been brought along in the first place. I said that as far as I knew the movie came closer to answering this than the book, that answer being that apparently hobbits are like teddy bears for Gandalf and he feels better when he's carrying one around with him. This actually is almost working for me; but then, I still massively ship Gandalf/Pippin.

comments

potentialities

Wednesday reading meme

Shipping all the Gandalf rarepairs