Dear Yuletide author,
I am so pleased that we share an interest in one of these fandoms and I can’t wait to read what you write for me this Yuletide!
I enjoy a wide variety of stories, all year round but especially at Yuletide. I love short, punchy stories and longer, plotter stories, explicitly smutty and/or kinky stories and coy stories that are all about the teasing and the implications, stories with some kind of meta angle to them and stories that engage with the source material 100% on its own terms, stories with ships that are canon and stories with ships that aren’t. I love when characters are weird about each other, especially when it doesn’t quite fit into any normal category.
I am mayhap on AO3 as well. I have checked to make sure I have gifts enabled, in case you are considering writing treats.
L’art du crime | The Art of Crime (TV)Alexandre Pardo
Antoine Verlay
Florence ChassagneCharacter exceptions: Okay to write a story focused on Antoine and Florence that doesn’t include Alex. Okay to write a story focused on Antoine and Alex that doesn’t include Florence.
I came here for the art history and the murders but they sucked me into the will-they-won’t-they relationship! Sometimes it starts feeling strained or contrived when the characters keep not getting together for so long, but with Antoine and Florence I can believe it—they’re both being utterly ridiculous, of course, but Antoine is so alienated from his own emotions and Florence is so overwhelmed by hers, it’s plausible they keep getting in their own way. I do very much want to see them them get together, but I also enjoy the pining and the denial. Established relationship fic that breezes through the actual get-together part is another great option! If you want to write some pure smut or some other such fic where it makes sense for it just to be Antoine and Florence, it’s okay to not include Alex, or only include him briefly.
Feel free to put in as much or as little of both art history and murders as you like. I really love the device of Florence’s imagined conversations with artists, if there’s anyone you’d like to have offer her their input. The fact that Antoine still doesn’t know that they shared a childhood connection with the little boy in the Monet painting is still hanging out there, waiting to perhaps return in an important moment. The Louvre is one of the greatest locations in the world and any amount of time spent there with anything in the collection is always a delight.
As we get into these later seasons, the writers seem to be indulging in more tropiness, as often happens in these sort of shows, and you could definitely lean into that side! Now that season eight is available in English, I really enjoyed the subplot of the novelist who wrote thinly-veiled versions of Florence and Antoine into her latest novel and caused a sensation, for example, and I’d love to dig even deeper into what the Antony Bellone/Chantal Flossagne shippers are up to, or something completely different but equally funny.
I’m also extremely fond of Alex! The premise requires kind of plot device to keep Antoine in OCBC in spite of the fact he so clearly does not belong, but he’s so charming about it, and he really rocks the combination of the dapper vests and eternally put-upon expressions. I’d really enjoy a story where he continues to be substantially involved in mediating their relationship, maybe even getting even more deeply enmeshed somehow, maybe even getting drawn into some kind of threesome? However, if that aspect doesn’t speak to you or you just have other ideas you want to explore, I don’t want to box you into anything at all.
I’d also really love to explore the origin story of Alex and Antoine’s friendship and especially what Antoine for Alex to cement their friendship and his sense of obligation towards him. If you want to focus on this, especially if the whole fic is set before they even meet her, it’s okay not to include Florence, or only include her briefly.
Season 9 hasn't been made available in English yet, but I've watched it in French. I don't necessarily expect anyone else to have seen it, but if you have, you don't need to worry about spoilers if you so choose.
Brothers (TV)Matthew McConaughey
Woody HarrelsonAlthough I loved their work together on True Detective, I didn’t particularly follow their careers and knew virtually nothing about their private lives* or friendship until they popped up on New Heights to promote this show. It turns out that they’re both lunatics, they’re delightfully weird about each other, and they created this whole ridiculous show about the real fact that they could possibly be brothers? I was sold.
The show is still airing, so I don’t know how they’ve chosen to end it, but so far it’s been silly and self-indulgent in exactly the way that I was hoping for. I like that it’s fictionalized, so there’s some dramaturgy and also actors playing all their family members, especially the minor children, but it’s still actually them, even when they’re making stuff up. I find their dynamic extremely shippable, and I’m very here for the possibility of making it an incest ship as well, but that’s just one option. Feel free to write a fic where they do hook up but aren’t brothers, are brothers, but strictly platonically, or indeed are neither brothers nor lovers, except in the sense that they love each other like brothers, which is an actual fact.
Crossover possibilities: If you want to do something meta incorporating Matthew and Woody, the real people, in their capacity as the creators of this show, as characters in the fic somehow, crossing it over with real life, so to speak, I do love that sort of thing and I think there’s a lot of potential for that inherent in the premise. Or if you wanted to somehow do a crossover or maybe more of a fusion with True Detective, it’s obviously wildly tonally different, but that sort of crossover-as-extreme-sport can be fun.
Mostly. I’d love to read whatever you come up with! Again, I don’t know how it’s going to end on the show, but feel free to write canon divergence starting from any point for any reason and not be bound by any plot developments that you find inconvenient, or just not as fun as other possibilities you’d rather write..
*I have since read McConaughey’s book and now know lots of things about his private life, including ones I did not necessarily need to know! It is certainly a wealth of characterization.
Inspector Alleyn Mysteries — Ngaio MarshJeremy Jones
Peregrine JayThe two Dolphin books have always been among my favorite Alleyn mysteries. There’s something so cozy about how Perry stumbles (quite literally) into having his dream theatre lavishly restored for him, a play that’s a success with the critics and the public (including Alleyn), a perfect ongoing artistic collaboration with his best friend, and a lovely wife. It could be too much if he didn’t have to deal with a murder from time to time and even then, it’s a pretty charmed life. I love how, unlike the other theatrical books in the series, Perry gets to indulge in Shakespeare, including writing his own RPF about him and putting all his own headcanons in it, which certainly feels like it was a lot of fun for Ngaio Marsh, as a veteran director and student of Shakespeare, to write.
I also love the subplot of the theft of the glove and its denouement is so deliciously emotionally fraught. I really sympathize with Jeremy’s miserable emotional state, while also agreeing with Perry and Alleyn that he’s extremely unappreciative of how fortunate he is to get off as lightly as he does. We never quite close the loop on it: Jeremy is still extremely raw and touchy in his last appearance in
Killer Dolphin, and then by
Light Thickens he’s had a long and productive association with the Dolphin and all is well and nothing about his private life is even mentioned.
I also really ship Perry/Jeremy. I recognize that this is canonically challenging, especially from Perry’s side, since we do have his point of view, including as he tries to work out whether his mysterious patron’s inscrutable motives are sexual and also his clumsy but well-intended allyship towards a gay actor in his cast. On Jeremy’s side, there could be slightly more ambiguity; I feel like his thing for Destiny Meade could be covering for something else precisely because it is so conspicuously hopeless, or maybe just some disaster bi behavior. I could also see Jeremy turning out to be queer in some way but leaving Perry straight and happily married
But don’t feel like you have to get into any of that at all if the idea doesn’t strike you favorably! I love the theatre stuff and I’d love any kind of story about them as friends and creative partners there. You could feature your own dream production of any of Shakespeare’s plays, with an infinite budget and full directorial control! (The Macbeth in
Light Thickens is my favorite one that I’ve ever seen, even though I’ve never technically seen it.) If you want to include Alleyn, Troy, Fox, etc. in any capacity, I love them all as well, and it wouldn’t need to be a mystery since Alleyn is connected to the theatre (but it could also be a mystery). If you want to get experimental, the Dolphin is practically a character in its own right and you could write something from its point of view, or the ghost of Mr. Adolphus Ruby, its former proprietor. I would really just love a story about my favorite one-off (or rather, two-off) characters.
Kansas City Royals RPF (Baseball RPF)Bobby Witt Jr.
Vinnie PasquantinoBobby and Vinnie have been sharing a house during spring training that they’ve dubbed the “Witz-Carleton,” and the MLB social team did a day in the life with them and put together
a little eleven-minute video this year. As a long-time Royals fan, I would say it is a nicely representative sample of what both of them are like as friends and teammates, as well as occasional roommates. You could use it as your whole basis for their personalities and dynamic and it’d probably be fine, honestly. This is essentially what they’re both like, at least whenever there’s a camera on them. Vinnie is louder and pushier and Bobby is much more chill in the way that he carries himself, but they both love to be funny and come up with bits and participate in each other’s bits, so they’re very alike in that way.
So the bromance is definitely very real. The straight guy energy at the Witz-Carleton is also pretty real, and I find it endearing. I think there’s still plenty for a shipper to work with here, don’t get me wrong, but I also think the vibes are immaculate as they are. Feel free to take whichever option entertains you the most and run with it.
This year, Bobby and Vinnie also got to take a turn as opponents during the World Baseball Classic, playing for Team USA and Team Italy respectively. Team Italy ended up being one of the best storylines of the WBC and that had a lot to do with Vinnie, who assumed a leadership role, set the tone, made espressos in the dugout for home run celebrations and was generally heart and soul of the team. Team USA, unfortunately, did not appear to be having nearly as much fun. I don’t think Bobby had a lot to do with choosing that, because he is more of a fun-haver, but he isn’t really the guy who would rock the boat if everyone seems to be wanting to do something else.
Team USA lost to Team Italy and then needed Italy to beat Mexico to bail them out of being eliminated during pool play, which they did. Vinnie
gave an interview on the field after that game where he said, “You’re welcome, USA,” and when the interviewer asked him what he thought his text message from Bobby would say, he responded, with a weird and possibly menacing intensity, “I’m hoping he’s got a room key for me at his hotel. That’s what I’m hoping.” What did he mean by this?? Much to explore here, if anyone so desires. Feel free to make it weirder. Including, but not limited to, weird sex things.
Mostly I am just hoping for some shenanigans and maybe some baseball, which is a great sport, even when your (my) team is losing. Have fun!
Plain Girl — Virginia SorensonEsther Lapp
MaryI love how delicately and yet powerfully this book explores Esther’s thoughts and feelings—about her family, the Amish community, their way of life, and of course about her new friend Mary, whom she finds so beautiful, not just for her pretty dresses, but also things like her silky hair and her dimpled elbows as well as her wonderful kindness and tact in welcoming her to school and becoming her bosom friend. It’s written as a seduction and that seduction is a good thing, a fountain that sends forth sweet water and not bitter. I see flashes of an eroticism as well, like Esther touching Mary’s hair and finding it so beautiful that a shiver goes through her fingers and her heart starts to beat very fast, or Mary showing Esther her petticoat when they’re planning to change clothes with each other, which I find really lovely.
Even though they don’t end up wearing each other’s clothes at school they must do it eventually, somewhere, sometime! I’d love for that to be explored in a story, at any age or perhaps more than once, as they get older. Anything exploring their relationship and how it develops in the future would be wonderful. There’s a lot of potential for angst and difficulty but also for love and sharing. Esther, of course, has her new sister-in-law and her brother in her corner when it comes to blending the old and the new, with her parents much more tentatively open, but Mary’s family is wide open for exploration, and so are the rest of their peers. I’d love gen or getting together or established relationship or pre-ship fic all equally.
The Professor — Charlotte BrontëFrances Evans Henri
Hunsden Yorke Hunsden
William CrimsworthI am fascinated the role that Hunsden Yorke Hunsden plays in this story, who is of the things that makes it different from Villette, which is essentially a heavily-revised second draft of The Professor. From the beginning he alternates between needling William and performing these extremely thoughtful favors for him, although it's not always easy for him to get under William's skin as William perversely enjoys some of his bluntness. He brings out such an interesting side of Frances when he meets her, too -- I love that promptly she gets into three arguments with him in a row, and the third time she doesn't even believe in the argument she's making; she just wants to fight with him!
I'm particularly interested in a story set when William and Frances are living in England and Hunsden is their neighbor. I love how he has apparently latched onto their family in lieu of starting their own, especially the way he seems to practically be a coparent to Victor when he’s at home. I would love more about their daily life as it's sketched all too briefly in that last chapter, or a story about something that happens as Victor gets older and goes to school, which William worries about.
I would also love threesome fic! William would be almost hopelessly scandalized by the prospect, I think, and surely Frances too, but then with the dynamic both she and Hunsden have with William where they love to tease him I can imagine it working out somehow. I do love stories where characters fumble their way into unusual relationships or sexual practices without quite knowing what they're doing or having the usual vocabulary to talk about it, which is sort of what I would picture here. But I absolutely would be just as happy with a story that explores the dynamic among them some other way.